Going back to the original title of this thread, for me it isn't so much what I believe as the journey that got me there.
My parents had a conversion experience to Christianity when I was young and there was little option but to go along with their new found faith. My father being a very driven person, went at it like a bull at a gate, through the gate and down the path to NTM. Whereas the people he associated with in his church were nice and pretty ordinary citizens, it was obvious to even a ten year old that NTM was intense when we arrived in training. There were some loveable characters and there were some hard nuts. For a good Christian organisation there were some pretty angry people and a good old fist fight on the soccer field was not uncommon. The censorship seemed a bit weird and the strange controling rules. But the theology was o.k. to go along with, because everyone else did. I thought it was over the top, but it was what life had dealt me. But then I realised we were preying on people to support our lifestyle, so that we could go and tell some people who we didn't know about someone who was from a far away culture, many centuries before and said he was God and it just didn't tally up with what I could see going on around me. Complicate this by the inquisitive mind of a young Bemused who wondered how with so many other faiths with far more adherents and wiser men, how could we just assume that we had all the answers.
Then we arrived in PNG and it got really weird. This was a different culture again, not just because most of the missionaries came from the other side of the world, but they were really into their religon and it was non stop theology and some of the loudest practitioners were just plain whacky (and also the school teachers and staff). But even when my parents agreed that my concerns about some of the individuals was valid, it came back to "the ends justifies the means" or as they coded it "take your eyes off sinful men and look to God", which sounded like mumbo jumbo escapism to a teenager with a lot of questions and few answers. And the constant repitition drove me nuts, for my thinking was "if it is so wonderfully true, why do I have to hear it over and over", so I just did enough to keep my personal safety and sanity in tact and my father off my back.
I survived the teenage years, got home and just got on with life. There was no one who would really believe my story (so I felt) so I left the church and pursued humanitarian and self sufficiency ideals. The big theological questions nagged away, but any attempt to clarify them only raised the uglyness of the NTM confusion and the ongoing problems with my father, so I just wandered on my own path.
Then bingo, what I suspected had been really going on in PNG turned out to be true, I had been right all along, but of course it was just the tip of the iceberg, the whole thing was one complete mess. And suddenly my Agnostic viewpoint had more validity and whatever brand of Protestantism that NTM was representing lost its credibility. The credibility was fatally flawed by those around me who bizzarely defended paedophiles and yet still proclaimed a Christian belief. For me the two are incompatable. There was no love for fellow humans, no empathy for victims, it was self preservation at all costs and the bending of the truth to do it.
As an Agnostic, I really shouldn't be here. This is not an Agnostics fight, it is the fight of good Christian people against those who badly disgrace the Christian faith. But here it gets complicated, for even though when I left PNG, I thought most of my fellow MKs were cowards, in that they stood and watched me become isolated and tormented, my humanitarian side says they also were there not of their freewill and those who were sexually abused deserve a better deal than what they got. Many have not been as fortunate as Bemused to have been able to get through the experience and make a go of life. And it is not in anyones interests to dismiss the suffering of other MKs as Karma and just wonder off with Agnostic doubts in tact. If an MK was abused by an adult and never seen justice for their actions, then there is a cause to fight for.
Which of course explains the journey to being a "Sympathetic Agnostic".
What I believe or have doubts about remains personal and only known to very close friends. For the greater good is the objective and that is to make sure this never happens again and those who are responsible for atrocities are put out of action and served justice.
"Sympathetic Agnostic" is just a label, I made it up. It's something I'm comfortable with. I don't need prayers to change the label, or messages of condolence. All I ask for is that we remove the fence that exists. Not the fence of labels, but the fence that the apathetic involved sit on and the paedophiles and their supporters hide behind, so that all who need to see, can look and see who is where in this awful mess.
And I said I wasn't going to say much on this subject, see even Sympathetic Agnostics can change their mind